Cane Syrup vs. Sorghum Molasses: What's the Difference?
Two jars sit beside each other on our shelf, dark and sweet and both headed for a biscuit. People pick up one, look at the other, and ask which is which.
What is the difference between cane syrup and sorghum?
Cane syrup is made from sugar cane. Sorghum is made from sorghum cane, a different plant grown for its juice. Both are pressed for their juice and cooked down until it thickens.
That is the whole difference in a sentence. Everything else follows from it.
Our cane syrup
Pure Cane Syrup is fresh ground cane cooked down in old-fashioned kettles, and it carries the fuller flavor of the two we make. Good on pancakes, waffles and biscuits, and over vanilla ice cream.
Country Syrup is the milder one, for when you want it to sit quieter on the plate. Biscuits, oatmeal, waffles, or straight into a recipe as the sweetener.
Our sorghum
100% Sorghum Molasses is cooked straight down from sorghum cane and bottled. Nothing cut into it to stretch it.
Ours is a mild one, which is worth saying because sorghum varies a good deal from one producer to the next. If you have had a strong, earthy sorghum somewhere else and decided it was not for you, that is not what is in this jar.
Can you substitute sorghum for cane syrup?
In most baking, yes. They pour alike and they sweeten alike. What changes is how much flavor comes along with the sweetness, so taste as you go rather than swapping blind in something delicate.
Pure Cane Syrup can also go in where a baking recipe calls for corn syrup. Candy is the exception: corn syrup is doing chemistry there, not just sweetening, so leave that one alone.
Which jar for what
- Pancakes and waffles: cane syrup.
- Hot biscuit and butter: either one.
- Cookies and gingerbread: sorghum.
- In place of corn syrup, in baking: Pure Cane Syrup.
- Over vanilla ice cream: cane syrup.
Neither one is blackstrap
Blackstrap is a different thing again, and worth knowing about so you do not buy it by mistake.
When sugar cane juice is boiled to crystallize sugar out of it, what is left gets boiled a second time, and a third. Blackstrap is what remains at the end, with most of the sugar already taken out, which is why it tastes bitter and mineral instead of sweet. It has its uses. A biscuit is not one of them.
Sorghum got called molasses out of habit a long time ago and the name stuck. It is its own syrup, cooked from its own juice.
All three are on the shelf at any of our four stores.